Intelligent Tolls

When a driver uses a busy road he is imposing a delay cost on all other drivers.  However, as road users we do not take the costs we impose on others into account, thus roads like most common resources are over used and society is worse off.

Road pricing is a method to try and internalise the costs drivers impose on others and to encourage more efficient use of the road network.  London use a congestion charge for cars entering the centre of London, and makes some mild claims about it's effectiveness.  The problem with the London congestion charge is that it is too blunt a tool.  It is a fixed charge that does not respond to demand and increased congestion.  When roads are moving freely the congestion charge should be low, when roads are choked the charge should be high to encourage drivers to find alternatives.  This is the basis of Vickrey congestion pricing.

Singapore is one of the best examples of Vickrey pricing in action.  Here is a recent report from the Financial Times and the video below the fold gives a television news report on the charges.

You can read more about Singapore's experiences with intelligent road pricing here and see also this fact sheet.  There is excellent article from Wired on The Ultimate Jam Session. IBM have been a key partner in the Electronic Road Pricing project in Singapore and produced a short TV TV ad  based on their contribution.  Some details of IBM's traffic prediction efforts are available here.

Here is a nice summary of congestion changes and an article on VoxEU has a simple cost-benefit analysis of the London congestion charge.  The New York Times discusses the possibility of uses congestion charges to speed up Manhattan's traffic.


  1. Thanks a lot for sharing this with all folks you really recognise what you are talking about! In this complex environment business need to present there company data in meaningful way.Sqiar ( which is in UK,provide services like Tableau and Data Warehousing etc .In these services sqiar experts convert company data into meaningful way.

    saya bersyukur kpd Allah SWT.
    atas keberhasilan PENARIKAN UANG
    GHAIB.setelah melalui proses panjang &
    sangat sangat beresiko,dgn izin Allah
    alhamdulillah uang ghaib akhirnya berhsil
    kami keluarkan dgn jumlah yg luar biasa.
    setelah uang balik (UB) sudah terbukti keberhasilanya,
    dan sehubungan banyaknya orang yang menginginkan hal ini
    ( UANG GHAIB ), kami sanggup memproses penarikan UANG GHAIB,
    dngan catatan:
    1.masalah utang piutang (JUMLAH BESAR)
    2.tidak untuk memperkaya diri
    3.sanggup menyiapkan satu ekor sapi jantan,(sebagai pengganti tumbal)
    bagi anda yang BENAR-BENAR SERIUS dalam hal ini.....
    silahkan menghubungi (PAK SUGENG ) DI NMR
    ( 082-315-999-679 )
    atau Atau klik disini
    Atau mau di bantuh togel 2D 3D 4D 5D 6D di jamin 100% tembus

  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

  4. Hay, saya micle hobi saya bermain di Situs Casino Online Terbaru yang dapat menghibur hari-hari saya. Ayo ikut join dan gabung bareng aku:v